Proudly supported by vanity fair

Newsletter

Receive regular updates about forthcoming events and other news from Intelligence Squared

Thanks

You have been added to our mailing list and will now be among the first to hear about events.

Play video1:24:31

Watch

Effective Altruism: A Better Way to Lead an Ethical Life

We all want to make a difference in our lives, but are we more concerned with feeling virtuous than actually doing good? Many of the standard ways of giving are far less effective than we think.

Almost all of us want to make a difference in our lives. So we give to charity, recycle, volunteer, or cut down our carbon emissions. But are we getting it right? In a world where ever more data is available, shouldn’t we be paying closer attention to the measurable effects of our altruistic actions? Why, for example do we spend so much time and effort researching hotels and restaurants online while we rarely bother to investigate the effectiveness of the charities we donate to? Are we more concerned with feeling good about ourselves than actually doing good?

Enter William MacAskill, rising star philosopher at Oxford University and co-founder of the Effective Altruism movement. MacAskill’s new book Doing Good Better has won acclaim from the likes of Peter Singer and Steven Pinker. Bill Gates, perhaps the world’s greatest philanthropist, has even described him as ‘a data nerd after my own heart.’ By crunching the numbers, MacAskill has shown that the standard ways of doing good often turn out to be less effective than we think. For example:

  • Giving to disaster relief is generally not the best way to help the poor.
  • Buying sweatshop produced goods generally reduces poverty.
  • Buying Fairtrade achieves little.
  • Typical 
charities do a hundred times less good than the best charities.

We need to be more rational and savvy, MacAskill argues, when it comes to giving, and we need to be willing to accept that the best ways to do good are often counterintuitive: If you want to reduce your carbon footprint, he claims, rather than buy local produce you should donate to offsetting charities. If you want to reduce animal suffering, you should first stop eating chicken, not beef. When choosing your career, working for a non-profit isn’t necessarily the most altruistic choice: you can achieve more good over your lifetime by taking a highly-paid job and donating a chunk of your earnings to worthwhile causes. And in order to have the biggest impact, forget the maxim that charity begins at home: you should give money to organisations that save lives in the developing world rather than those that help people at the bottom of the pile in your own rich country.

But not everyone agrees with MacAskill’s utilitarian approach to altruism. Sharing the stage with him in this Intelligence Squared event will be priest and philosopher Giles Fraser. To Fraser, the important point is that we are people, not algorithms, and our personal attachments and loyalties are an important part of our identities. So if it comes a choice between spending a few hours consoling a bereaved friend, or using that time to earn money to give to a good cause, don’t the fundamental requirements of kindness and empathy – the qualities that make us human – make consoling the friend the correct ethical choice? And can it really be right for an individual to choose a dispiriting but lucrative career spanning decades in order to fund a deworming initiative in Africa?

These are some of the ethical challenges that BBC business editor Kamal Ahmed steered our speakers through. In the front row we had heads of charities, philosophers and philanthropists to take part in the discussion.


Speakers

Chair

Kamal Ahmed

Editorial director of BBC News and former BBC economics editor


BBC editorial director, former economics editor, and author of The Life and Times of a Very British Man, a book about race and identity in Britain.
Featuring

William MacAskill

Co-founder of the Effective Altruism movement


Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of Oxford, co-founder of the Effective Altruism movement, and co-founder of the non-profits Giving What We Can and 80,000 Hours, which inspire people to use their time and money as effectively as possible to fight the world’s most pressing problems. He has pledged to donate everything he earns above £20,000 to whatever organisations he believes will do the most good.

Giles Fraser

Priest and broadcaster


Parish priest at St Mary’s Newington in south London. He was canon chancellor of St Paul’s Cathedral until he resigned in 2011 over the treatment of the Occupy protesters camped outside the cathedral. He writes the Loose Canon column for the Guardian and is a regular broadcaster on BBC Radio 4.