Western liberal democracy would be wrong for China
Wednesday November 7 2012 | Video now onlineAdd to Calendar >
Watch the video
Listen to the podcast
People everywhere are better off living in liberal democracy: that has been the reigning assumption of the western world. But could it be we’ve got it wrong? If you were one of the world’s billions of poor peasants might you not be better off under a system dedicated to political stability and economic growth – one that has lifted 400 million out of poverty – rather than one preoccupied with human rights, the rule of law, and the chance to vote out unpopular rulers? Thanks to the Chinese model of government life expectancy in Shanghai is now higher than in New York.
So is China better off without democracy? Or is that just the age-old mantra of the tyrant? That’s the clash of civilisations that played out on November 7th.
Speakers for the motion
Author of When China Rules the World, visiting senior research fellow at the London School of Economics, and visiting professor at Tsinghua University, Beijing
Senior Fellow at the Chunqiu Institute, author of The China Wave: the Rise of a Civilizational State, and former translator to Deng Xiaoping
Speakers against the motion
Former Chief Secretary of Hong Kong and campaigner for democracy
Historian of China, and former China correspondent for The Observer and East Asia editor of The Times
Inaugural Dean of the Blavatnik School of Government and Professor of Global Economic Governance at Oxford University