America has lost its moral authority

America has lost its moral authority

29 Apr 2008

In light of America's involvement in controversial wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and the American government's use of torture and rendition, the panel question America's moral authority.

Speaking for the motion are Professor John Gray, Matthew Parris and Will Self. Will Self begins by questioning the American idea of democracy since 9/11, highlighting a heterogeneous system of Inequalities that powerfully disenfranchises the American people, and attempts to present itself as an economy that should be listened to. Professor John Gray agrees with Will Self, choosing to focus on the moral question of torture over geo-politics and economics. Matthew Parris urges the floor to support the motion in its spirit, not its letter; stating that America never did have the moral authority to lose – that she had lost the appearance of one.

Arguing against the motion Simon Schama draws the attention to a moral re-awakening in the American people led by key politicians. Martin Amis approaches the motion along the scenic route describing the American in its common adjective use – granting an idealism and moralistic quality. Finally Howard Jacobson asks that if America has indeed lost the moral high ground then to whom? And who are we to pass judgement?

First Vote: 431 For, 143 Against, 176 Don’t Know

Final Vote: 433 For, 291 Against, 37 Don’t know