17 Jun 2009
The panel discuss the theory that psychotherapy has done more harm than good.
Arguing in favour of the proposal are Theodore Dalrymple, Dorothy Rowe and Jeffrey Masson. Theodore Dalrymple begins by arguing that the negative cultural effect of psychotherapy outweighs any potential good done to individual patients. He believes it elevates feelings over objective evidence, and treats human life as a technical problem to be solved - standing in the way of human happiness. Dorothy Rowe states that therapy can help, on very rare occasions; however, nobody really knows how this occurs. Whilst therapists must take account of everything in a person’s life, any therapy that is unable to do this causes harm. Finally, Jeffrey Masson states that the prejudices of the therapist affect the participants; however, participants cannot know the background of the therapist. Therapists' abilities are also deeply limited as no one is an expert when it comes to sorrow, happiness, or love.
Arguing against the proposal are Andrew Samuels, Lorna Martin and Professor Lord Layard. Andrew Samuels begins by arguing that psychotherapy does not create a victim mentality - in fact, it has the opposite effect. He states that growth and risk are connected, while anti-psychotherapy belief comes from upper middle-class repression. Lorna Martin believes that psychotherapy is not a cure for the human condition, but it helps you understand what your “default position” is. She rejects the notion that it has caused the human condition to become medicalised - this has occurred from outside influences. Professor Lord Layard states that therapy is exactly the same as medicine – meaning there are good and bad practitioners. He believes that Cognitive Behaviour Therapy saves lives, and strongly supports the increased role of mental health services offered through the NHS.
First vote: 167 For, 304 Against, 195 Don't Know
Final vote: 204 For, 421 Against, 35 Don't Know
Motion defeated by 217 votes.
BUY THE DVD
Season tickets are £100 each and include one ticket and a glass of wine for all five debates in our autumn 2010 series
Buy tickets
Buy tickets for 'Don't eat animals' on December 9, featuring Peter Singer, Heather Mills, Paul Levy and Julian Baggini
Buy tickets
See all of the latest IQ² content on one page, including written debates, live debates, and talks from our partners
See what's new
Elizabeth, author of the best-selling Eat, Pray, Love, will talk about her life and writing at this exclusive IQ² event on September 15
Buy ticketsThis week, The Magazine brings you both sides of the story on the legalisation of cocaine, plus debates on philanthrocapitalism and Iran
See the magazine
Copyright 2010 Intelligence 2 Ltd | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | User Guidelines | Goodies