You are not signed in Sign in | Contact Us

The deliberate bombing of civilians can never be justified



Jump straight into the debate

A. Area bombing of Germany in World War Two was a war crime

B. The bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was unjustified

C. The area-bombing of Dresden in February 1945 was a war crime

Background

Strategic bombing, when air attacks are carried out in order to disrupt production, transportation and communications, and lower civilian morale, was first advocated in the period between the two world wars. Military theorists believed that it offered the prospect of ending conflict quickly and avoiding the useless slaughter of static battles on the ground.

Read more

That was before the atrocities of the Second World War, during which the Luftwaffe brought the terror of the Blitz to London, and Allied bombers killed hundreds of thousands of German civilians in Berlin, Hamburg and Dresden. It was before the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki heralded a world in which whole cities could be destroyed by the press of a button.

So, after the Germans and Japanese surrendered, a debate began about whether the military results outweighed the human cost of indiscriminate bombing, and some said that the British and American attacks of 1944 and 1945 deserved to be classed as “war crimes”. Though strategic bombing was still used in subsequent conflicts such as the Vietnam War, a growing revulsion led, in 1977, to a protocol being added to the fourth Geneva convention. This outlawed civilian bombing.

In recent years, beginning with the First Gulf War, strategic bombing campaigns have used much more precise weaponry. Now, unmanned drones directed by pilots in the Nevada desert can strike targets in the mountains in Afghanistan. But though these are getting ever more accurate, they still kill many more civilians than they do militants, and the question of whether they should be allowed continues to be asked.

download pdf Printer Friendly version

Iran debate

"What to do about Iran?", featuring Daniel Levy, Fawaz Gerges, and Roxane Farmanfarmaian, RGS, 7th June

Buy tickets

Thomas Friedman

One of America's most influential columnists on the decline of America, at the Royal Institution, 13th June 2012

Buy tickets

Eagleman talk

American neuroscientist David Eagleman on the science of hatred and dehumanisation, RIBA, 24th May 2012

Buy tickets

IQ² GLOBAL

USA

Asia

Australia

Ukraine

Greece



Copyright 2011 Intelligence 2 Ltd | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | User Guidelines | Goodies | FAQs